We have a winner, sort of
Part two of our rebrand, from PILLAR’s founder, Eddie Kaufholz: four rounds of options, the business card that settled it, and the brand guide that keeps the rest of us from breaking it.

In part one, I told the story of our name and the homemade logo it wore for two years. This is how Ashley Purser built what replaced it, over four rounds and seven weeks, with a deadline of April 1, PILLAR’s birthday.
My brief was short. The logo had to work as small as the little circle on an Instagram profile. It had to hold up in one color beside other organizations’ logos. And it had to last long enough to carry what we’d build next, starting with the PILLAR Co-Op.
By the second round, Ashley had five options on the table. My friends’ favorite was a much better version of the old logo, so I passed on it. If we were going to change, we were going all the way. Two pieces survived from two other options: the italic PILLAR and the art deco column.
Then came a business card. I had seen so many mockups of so many things, and none of them settled it. The card did. Ashley had set the italic wordmark, the column, and our colors together on Pine, and I kept going back to it.
On March 19, I wrote to tell her we had a winner, sort of. I loved the card, but I couldn’t find its logo among the options. It was option 03c, and it had been in front of me all along. The next day, she asked if I liked the fonts on the card. This was my whole reply:
I loved the business card. No notes.
That was the moment the logo was done.
The colors took longer. Pine and Tangerine worked from the start. But whenever Matcha took up real space on a white page, I fell out of love with the whole palette. I sent Ashley a few colors I liked and asked her to push back. She did, with more options and some advice:
If you go with Matcha, I don’t want you to always look at it like the weird in-law you begrudgingly invite to events.
In the end, the fix was in the Pine, which lost a little saturation and went a touch darker, to #384948. Matcha stayed, and today it closes every page of this website.
Two days into the work, I had asked Ashley for one more thing: “I’m very likely to break something if I don’t have guardrails, which is the story of my whole freaking life.” Her brand guide is those guardrails.
Every brand needs guardrails, because the designer won’t be in the room for most of what happens to it. A guide is what you hand to anyone who touches the brand: a new designer, a printer, a partner putting your logo on their website. It lets them get it right the first time without starting from scratch. And it makes everything look like it came from one place, which is how people come to recognize a brand and trust it.
Ours sets the wordmark and the column in four official configurations, with rules for minimum size and clear space.
It pairs our colors for text, ten ways that work and ten that never do, so nobody has to guess whether Tangerine can sit on white. (It can’t.) And it sets the type: Syne for headlines, IvyMode for italic accents, and Inter for body copy. On this website, Cormorant Garamond stands in for IvyMode.
On April 1, as she finished the last updates, Ashley wished PILLAR a happy birthday and wrote, “Thank you for trusting me with this project, it really does mean a lot.” This fall, she rebuilt the guide and added a section on texture.
You can see the whole thing for yourself. Download the PILLAR brand guide (PDF).
A logo is the part of a brand people see. The guide is the part that keeps it looking like itself after it leaves the designer’s hands, and it’s the reason I haven’t broken anything yet.